Santa Ana City Council orders independent investigation into videoed police beating
A cellphone video showing Santa Ana police repeatedly striking Florentino Lopez has prompted two investigations into the officers’ conduct.
[reporting: Santa Ana Council Chambers]
Five days after cellphone footage showed Santa Ana police officers repeatedly striking Florentino Lopez Jr. during an arrest, the City Council unanimously voted Oct. 6 to authorize an independent investigation that would report directly to councilmembers.
The decision followed growing public concern over the Oct. 1 encounter near Jackson and Fifth streets, where video recorded by relatives and neighbors showed officers taking Lopez to the pavement, repeatedly punching him and using knee strikes as family members pleaded for them to stop.
The recording does not show how the encounter began.
Following a closed-session discussion, Mayor Valerie Amezcua announced that the council had directed City Attorney Sonia Carvalho and City Manager Alvaro Nuñez to hire an independent investigator under Section 1100 of the Santa Ana City Charter.
The provision allows the council and city manager to investigate city departments and officers, including through subpoenas, sworn testimony and the production of evidence.
"In the history of Santa Ana, we have never acted so swiftly that within five days we are sitting here having a closed session on this item and bringing it to the public," Amezcua said.
The city subsequently clarified that two separate investigations would examine the arrest.
The first is an administrative investigation into whether the officers violated Santa Ana Police Department policies and whether disciplinary action may be warranted.
Such reviews are ordinarily conducted by the department's Internal Affairs Division. In this case, Police Chief Robert Rodriguez recommended an outside review, and the city manager decided to assign it to a third party.
The second investigation, authorized under Section 1100, will report directly to the City Council. Beyond examining the encounter, it can consider whether department policies, procedures or practices should change.
The council also unanimously directed the city to release the officers' names and related body-worn camera, audio and video recordings if it is legally determined that Lopez suffered great bodily injury resulting from the use of force.
The action did not require immediate disclosure.
Santa Ana City Council discussing action taken during Tuesday's closed-session portion of the meeting. [City of Santa Ana]
Mayor Pro Tem David Penaloza revealed that councilmembers had already viewed police body-camera footage that had not been released publicly.
"The video on social media, as well as the body cam footage that we all saw, at least we did up here. It was disturbing and disappointing," Penaloza said.
He urged city officials to complete the investigation without unnecessary delays.
Although all seven councilmembers supported the investigations, their remarks reflected different approaches to the officers' conduct and the city's responsibilities.
Councilmember Benjamin Vazquez said the incident raised questions about leadership and accountability extending beyond the police department.
"At the end of the day, this happened on our watch," Vazquez said.
Councilmember Jessie Lopez, who is not related to Florentino Lopez, said officers have a responsibility to de-escalate encounters and acknowledged the distress experienced by relatives watching the arrest.
"It's really difficult to ask members of our community to trust their local government, to trust their representatives when you feel that these things often happen," she said.
Councilmember Johnathan Ryan Hernandez called on Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer to dismiss the charges then pending against Lopez and investigate whether the officers should face criminal prosecution.
Councilmember Phil Bacerra urged restraint until investigators reviewed the evidence.
"The video definitely raised some serious concerns for me, but I'm gonna resist the temptation to make declarations about the situation until the independent investigation is complete," Bacerra said.
Councilmember Thai Viet Phan emphasized that disciplinary proceedings must comply with California's Public Safety Officers Procedural Bill of Rights Act, which establishes protections for officers during investigations.
"If we want to hold wrongdoers accountable, we have to follow the process," Phan said.
For Lopez's family, the investigation represents an opportunity to examine conduct they believe warrants accountability.
"My hope is that this case will bring greater awareness to the many other cases that have been overlooked or swept under the rug," his sister, Alex Lopez, told The Santanero.
Maribel Michaca, mother of Jaden Michaca, pleads to the Council for release of unedited body camera footage and urges reform in policing with emphasis on mental health deescalation tactics. (City of Santa Ana)
The discussion also brought attention to another Santa Ana family seeking answers.
Maribel Michaca, whose 15-year-old son Jaden Michaca was fatally shot by Santa Ana police in June, urged the council to release complete, unedited body-camera footage of her son's encounter.
She called for improved mental-health responses and de-escalation training.
"I wanted the help that he needed," Michaca said, describing why she had previously contacted police.
Santa Ana Police Officers Association President John Kachirisky told The Santanero that the association supports a fair investigation based on evidence.
"We support a thorough, fair and unbiased investigation that is based on the facts and evidence of the case," he said.