Santa Ana City Council cancels ALPR contracts effective immediately
City-operated license plate reader cameras ordered offline effective 9:46 PM Tuesday, while privately owned cameras remain unaffected.
The Santa Ana City Council voted tonight to approve Option A, directing the City Manager to terminate the city's agreements with Flock Group, Inc. and Motorola Solutions, Inc., effectively ending the city's Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) program.
The council also directed that the city's cameras be taken offline immediately, with the decision coming at approximately 9:46 PM.
The vote follows growing scrutiny of the controversial surveillance technology and concerns surrounding privacy, data sharing, and the use of license plate readers throughout Santa Ana.
Mayor Valerie Amezcua, in one of her final acts as mayor, supported terminating the contracts but expressed reservations about directing private businesses and property owners on what they can do with surveillance equipment on their own properties. She urged city staff to consider those concerns.
Councilmember Thai Viet Phan said she would ask Flock and Motorola to refund or waive fees in light of the negative publicity the companies have received.
Councilmember Jessie Lopez, who originally voted against the original contracts in 2025, called tonight's decision a "first step in the right direction."
Lopez said she would encourage private property owners and businesses operating license plate reader cameras, including major retailers such as Home Depot and Walmart, to reconsider their use of the technology.
However, she acknowledged that attempting to regulate cameras on private property could encroach on property rights. She emphasized that tonight's council action affects only city-operated cameras, not cameras installed or operated by private businesses and property owners.
Lopez also welcomed additional legal analysis for the incoming City Council and the public regarding what authority the city may have over privately operated surveillance cameras.
Councilmember David Penaloza similarly acknowledged that the city has "no control" over what private property owners do on their own properties, meaning privately operated license plate readers may continue to exist throughout Santa Ana despite the city's decision.
City Attorney Sonia Carvalho informed the council that her legal team had advised her of ongoing legal analysis concerning the city's potential authority over cameras operated on private property.
The council's decision directs the termination of the city's contracts and the immediate shutdown of its ALPR cameras. However, the city's own staff report warns that neither agreement allows termination simply for convenience.
According to the Nov. 17 staff report, the city faces approximately $482,227 in remaining scheduled contractual obligations — $131,040 to Flock and $351,187 to Motorola. The report also identifies potential additional financial exposure under Motorola's agreement.
zThe distinction is important: Santa Ana has voted to shut down its government-operated license plate reader program, but privately owned cameras are not covered by tonight's action.
The decision marks a significant reversal from May 2025, when the City Council originally approved the technology.